The Mummy That Came in From the Cold

BY AWAKE! CORRESPONDENT IN ITALY

At first sight it might have seemed like the scene of a crime. A dried-​out corpse lay facedown, half trapped in the ice. An accidental death? A revenge killing? Or simply another mountain-​climbing victim? In any case, what was he doing there in the silence of the Tirolean Alps 10,500 feet [3,200 m] above sea level? Who was he? And how did he die?

THE “Iceman,” as he was immediately named, or Homo tyrolensis, as scientists call him, was found by chance in September 1991 by a German couple hiking on Mount Similaun (in the Ötztaler Alps), on the Austria-​Italy border. The particularly hot summer that year had melted most of the snow, bringing to light remains that would otherwise have lain hidden​—for who knows how long? After investigators resolved some initial uncertainty about the find, the body was crudely hacked out of the ice, suffering damage in the course of the extraction. It soon became clear, however, that it was not an ordinary corpse. Near the body lay several objects that were very different from those normally used by modern hikers who venture to such altitudes.

Some realized that the corpse was very old. After the first tests, Konrad Spindler, of Innsbruck University, Austria, made a surprising statement​—that the mummified body found on Mount Similaun was some thousands of years old! Further analysis and research on the site led scholars to conclude that the corpse they were examining was “by far the most ancient human being ever found virtually intact.” (Time, October 26, 1992) Archaeologists believe that the Iceman, nicknamed Ötzi (from Ötztal, the German name of a nearby valley), died about 3000 B.C.E.

Once the importance of the find was appreciated, archaeologists returned several times to Mount Similaun to search for other artifacts useful in trying to understand what had happened to that man all those centuries ago. What have they discovered? Why has there been so much interest in a mummy entombed in the ice? Has it been possible to unravel any of the mystery surrounding him?

[Picture on page 3]

Ötzi, the Iceman

[Credit Line]

Foto: Archiv Österreichischer Alpenverein/​Innsbruck, S.N.S. Pressebild GmbH

Clues to the Mystery of the Iceman

FOR centuries, Ötzi was in a good resting-​place. He lay over 10,500 feet [3,200 m] above sea level in a narrow, snow-​filled ravine in a hollow that protected him from the movements of the nearby glacier. If his body had been frozen into the glacial ice mass, it would have been completely broken up and swept away. Very likely, his sheltered position preserved him intact.

Within a few yards [meters] of the body were objects that had apparently been a part of his everyday life: an unstrung yew-wood bow, a buckskin quiver with 14 arrows (2 ready for use, the others still to be finished), a flint-​bladed dagger, an ax, an object that is thought to be the frame for a primitive pack, a leather bag, a birch-​bark receptacle, and fragments of clothing, as well as other utensils and objects.

When he was found, Similaun Man (another of his names) was still wearing some of his articles of clothing and had on leather footwear stuffed with straw for protection from the cold. Near his head lay a “mat” of woven straw. It was as though, overcome by tiredness and the cold one evening, the Iceman fell tranquilly asleep only to “see” the light of day thousands of years later. The find was “a snapshot of an epoch, of a society and a biological population,” says archaeologist Francesco Fedele, who defined the Similaun Man as “a time capsule.”

How Was He Preserved?

Not all agree on the way Ötzi was preserved intact for so long in those conditions. “His preservation is little short of miraculous, even allowing for the alleged protection from the depression in which he was found,” says Nature. The theory that is currently thought to be the most plausible is that preservation occurred because of a combination of “three improbable events”: (1) a rapid process of natural mummification (dehydration), the result of the effects of the cold, the sun, and the foehn (a warm, dry wind); (2) a quick coverage by snow that hid the body from predators; and (3) the protection from moving glaciers afforded by the depression. Some, however, do not find even this explanation convincing, affirming that the foehn does not reach so high in this part of the Alps.

Some things about the Iceman are certain, however. It has been possible to ascertain that he was between 25 and 40 years of age, was about five feet two inches [160 cm] tall, and weighed about 110 pounds [50 kg]. He was wiry and muscular, and his brown hair was well cared for and was apparently cut regularly. Recent DNA studies of tissue samples have established that he belonged to the same gene pool as contemporary central and northern European inhabitants. His worn teeth reveal that he ate coarse bread, suggesting that he may have belonged to an agricultural community, as evidenced by the grains of wheat found in his clothing. Interestingly, it has been possible to determine that he died toward the end of summer or the beginning of autumn. How? In his bag were found the remains of a variety of wild plum that ripens in late summer; perhaps, they were a part of his last supplies.

“A Medieval Cavalier Carrying a Rifle”

But what does Ötzi reveal? The Italian journal Archeo summarized a number of questions raised by the discovery in this way: “Was he a warrior or a hunter? Was he an isolated individual, was he traveling with his group, or again, was he in transit on those mountains in the company of a small select part of his group? . . . Was he alone, surrounded by all that ice, or can we expect other presences?” Scholars have sought to ascertain the answers mainly through examination of the objects found on Mount Similaun and attempts to decipher their meaning. Various theories as to why Ötzi found himself at an elevation of more than 10,500 feet [3,200 meters] have been suggested, but each one of them is contradicted by some other detail. Let’s consider a few examples.

The bow, which had never been strung, and the arrows would immediately suggest that he was a hunter. Does that resolve the enigma? Perhaps, but the bow, with a length of nearly six feet [1.8 m], “was very big for a man of his stature,” says archaeologist Christopher Bergman, and “decidedly oversized to hunt typical Alpine game.” Why would he have a bow that he could not use? Furthermore, a person traveling in the mountains needs to shed all excess weight, “which makes it particularly puzzling that the man’s bow and 12 of his 14 arrows were unfinished, whereas his other weapons (dagger and axe) were worn by prolonged use,” observes Nature.

What about the ax that was found just a few yards [meters] away? At first, it was thought to be bronze, but tests revealed that, in reality, it was made of copper. For this and other reasons, many archaeologists are inclined to date Ötzi back to the beginning of the so-​called Copper Age, that is, the fourth-​third millennium B.C.E. “Carbon 14 tests . . . confirmed that he had lived between 4,800 and 5,500 years ago,” stated the magazine Audubon.a Other objects, however, would tend to persuade some experts to place the Iceman in a slightly older period. Apparently, it is not possible to assign Similaun Man to a particular ancient civilization. Referring to the copper ax, one archaeologist believes that Ötzi “possessed a weapon that was too technologically advanced for the epoch in which he lived. It was as though we had found a medieval cavalier carrying a rifle. In fact, in that epoch, copper was known only in Oriental cultures.”

Further, as we have already seen, the ax could have been a very precious object among the Iceman’s contemporaries. Other artifacts, such as the sheath for his dagger, were also extremely refined and were evidently “objects of prestige.” But if Ötzi was a high-​ranking personage, a chief, why was he alone at the time of his death?

According to Popular Science magazine, Konrad Spindler, of the University of Innsbruck, opined: “What were originally thought to be enigmatic tattoos correspond exactly to worn knee and ankle joints and degenerating vertebrae in his spine. The Iceman’s doctor probably treated the condition by branding the skin above the aching area, then rubbing herb ash into the wound.”

Recently, the idea was advanced, in a meeting of forensic medical experts in Chicago, that Ötzi may have been a beaten and bloodied fugitive who died in hiding while others hunted him. It has been determined that he had several broken ribs and a fractured jaw. However, it cannot be said exactly when he suffered these injuries​—before or after death. If he had been the victim of violence, though, “why did he still have all his implements, even ‘precious’ ones?” such as the copper ax, asks Archeo.

The investigators reckon that the facts available are not sufficient to complete the picture, and many questions still remain unanswered. But it is clear that the civilization Ötzi belonged to was highly structured and complex.

Ötzi and His World

In describing Similaun Man’s world, scholars base their opinions on finds from Alpine sites that are thought to have been inhabited by his contemporaries. Even then, archaeologists tell us, some areas were more developed than others, and most technical innovations, such as working in copper, originated in the Middle East.

According to one reconstruction, Ötzi may have lived in one of the agricultural villages of the Adige River basin. This river was an important trade route connecting the Italic Peninsula with Central Europe. A number of settlements have been found in various places in that part of the Alps, even at an altitude of some 6,500 feet [2,000 m]. Agricultural villages of the period were typically made up of three or four houses, perhaps a few dozen at most. What kind of houses? Excavations have brought to light only the floors, almost always of beaten earth. The dwellings had a single room, generally with a hearth in the center and sometimes an oven. The roof may have been gabled, similar to contemporary dwellings built on piles that were found close to a number of Alpine lakes. Every single-​room hut probably accommodated one family unit.

What kind of contacts were there between such communities of livestock raisers and farmers? Undoubtedly, trade. For example, the ax found on Mount Similaun was similar to those manufactured farther south, on the shores of Lake Garda, and may have been the object of a commercial transaction. Also among Ötzi’s equipment were some flints, objects precious in trade along the Adige Valley route. One of the activities that necessitated larger-​scale movements was the seasonal migration of livestock. As they still do in the Tirol today, shepherds led their flocks over Alpine passes in search of fresh pastures. What other conclusions have been reached on the Iceman’s origin?

[Footnotes]

[Map on page 5]

(For fully formatted text, see publication)

The Iceman was found just inside the Italian border on the Similaun Glacier

GERMANY

AUSTRIA

Innsbruck

SWITZERLAND

SLOVENIA

ITALY

Bolzano

Similaun Glacier

Adriatic Sea

[Pictures on page 7]

X marks the spot where Ötzi was found. Insets: 1. Copper ax, 2. Flint dagger, 3. Possibly an amulet, 4. Antler point in wood handle

[Credit Lines]

Foto: Prof. Dr. Gernot Patzelt/​Innsbruck

Fotos 1-4: Archiv Österreichischer Alpenverein/​Innsbruck, S.N.S. Pressebild GmbH

Insight Into the Iceman’s Mind and World

LET’s go back to Ötzi. Was he primitive, stupid, and devoid of aesthetic sensibilities? What do his utensils, his weapons, and his clothes reveal?

His weapons reveal that Ötzi had an excellent knowledge of ballistics. The two finished arrows had the characteristic feathers at the butt. The feathers were glued at an angle to make the arrow spin in flight, permitting a fair degree of accuracy up to a range of some 30 yards [30 m]. His leather clothes (various animal skins) tell us something of the tastes of the period. Today, a garment needs not only to cover but also to satisfy certain aesthetic requirements. What about in Ötzi’s day? Describing the finds, Time magazine says: “The robe had been cleverly whipstitched together with threads of sinew or plant fiber, in what appears to be a mosaic-​like pattern.” Both the pieces and the deliberate manner in which they had been sewn contributed to creating a “patchwork effect,” says the book Der Mann im Eis (The Man in the Ice). Over the tunic, the Iceman wore “a woven grass cloak, ideal for protection from the cold, which during a break could have been used as a ‘mattress’ to isolate his body from the ground.”​—Focus.

“An unexpected degree of sophistication” in his equipment was also noted, comments Time. The dagger, for example, was complete with “a finely crafted sheath, made from woven vegetation.” The Iceman, then, apparently lived in an epoch that was truly “rich and culturally intense,” as Giovanni Maria Pace defines it in his book Gli italiani dell’Età della pietra (Italians of the Stone Age).

Mention could also be made of the mushrooms found near Ötzi. They may have served to start a fire, but more likely, say experts, the Iceman had them with him for their antibiotic and therapeutic properties, part of a kind of portable “first-​aid kit.”

Aesthetic taste, intellectual capacity, therapeutic knowledge, and know-​how in the fields of metalworking, agriculture, and art​—these indicate, in contrast with the image often presented, that contemporaries of the Iceman were knowledgeable and competent in diverse fields. British archaeologist Dr. Lawrence Barfield stated: “Few of us today have any of the skills which most people would have had during the fourth millennium [B.C.E.].” Their refined tastes emerge, for example, in artistic depictions and metal and ceramic artifacts recovered from tombs.

The Religious Climate

“As far as scholars have discovered, there has never existed any people, anywhere, at any time, who were not in some sense religious,” says The New Encyclopædia Britannica. Speaking of the prominent role that religion played in ancient times, the Dizionario delle religioni (Dictionary of Religions) says that “compared to those used in everyday life, a disproportionate amount of goods and energies were employed in religious projects.”

The religious sentiment of Ötzi’s time was evidently very prevalent. In many places, ancient burial sites have been found that attest to the variety and richness of funeral rituals. Dozens of clay figurines have also been found that depict divinities belonging to ancient pantheons.

Ancient Human History and the Bible

The civilizations that emerge from research into ancient times, then, were quite complex. The picture is not one of primitive civilizations struggling, among a thousand difficulties, to make almost imperceptible progress toward a fully formed society. As far as historians are concerned, communities were of varying sizes but fully formed.

This is meaningful for any who study the Bible. The book of Genesis indicates that very early in human history​—and particularly as humankind ‘scattered over all the surface of the earth’—​complex and fully formed civilizations appeared, the elements of which had intellectual and spiritual capacities.​—Genesis 11:8, 9.

The Bible testifies that technical and artistic abilities were possessed by mankind even in the very earliest times, such as the forging “of every sort of tool of copper and iron.” (Genesis 4:20-22) According to the Bible record, human beings have always had the conscious desire to worship some deity. (Genesis 4:3, 4; 5:21-24; 6:8, 9; 8:20; Hebrews 11:27) Even though his religiosity degraded with the passing of time, man remains “incurably religious,” says The New Encyclopædia Britannica.

The Search for Origins

Although archaeological research is not able to answer all the questions posed by the discovery of Ötzi, it has nonetheless enabled us to gain some insight into the world in which he lived​—a complex world, very different from the usual image of so-​called prehistoric times. It was much more modern than many believe.

In conclusion, apart from the facts deduced from the Iceman’s appearance and belongings, as National Geographic stated, “almost everything else about him is part mystery, part speculation.” Meanwhile, Ötzi lies in a cold chamber in Innsbruck, Austria, while over 140 authorities in various disciplines struggle to resolve further mysteries of the Iceman who came in from the cold.

[Picture on page 8]

Forensic experts examine the Iceman’s body in Innsbruck

[Credit Line]

Foto: Archiv Österreichischer Alpenverein/​Innsbruck, S.N.S. Pressebild GmbH