Watchtower ONLINE LIBRARY
Watchtower
ONLINE LIBRARY
English
  • BIBLE
  • PUBLICATIONS
  • MEETINGS
  • How Can You Identify God’s Truth?
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 2

      How Can You Identify God’s Truth?

      How can we distinguish the word of God from the word of men—the true from the false? Well, in any dispute over a merchant’s weights, would we not check the weights’ official seals to determine the matter? Likewise, if we are to worship our Maker in love and in truth, we need to check the basic credentials of holy writings.

      2 As we have seen, only God can satisfy our spiritual needs, so we can expect scripture from him to magnify God and answer our questions about him, such as, Who is God? Why did he create us? How should we worship him? Why is there so much suffering, and will the human family ever live together in lasting happiness? These basic questions affect each one of us. How does God answer them?

      3 Loving parents never overlook the needs of any of their children. Similarly, we would expect God to make his holy writings available to all members of his human family. If those writings were available only in Sanskrit or Gurmukhi, for example, not all people would be able to benefit, would they?

      4 A kind father, even if highly educated, always speaks to his children on their level of understanding. Likewise, scriptures from God must be easy to understand. Says Paul, a preacher of the first century of our Common Era: “I would rather speak five words that can be understood, in order to teach others, than speak thousands of words in strange tongues.”—1 Corinthians 14:19, Today’s English Version.

      5 We resent being deceived and told lies. Rather, we are drawn to people who speak the truth. Honesty conveys a feeling of trust and confidence. Since our sense of right and wrong originates with our Maker, he cannot speak falsehood. We expect him to teach true doctrines and morals and to be accurate when referring to historical events.

      6 How, then, should we view scriptures that present myths as history? As we shall see, myths, unlike truth, differ widely and sometimes portray God as being weak or immoral. God’s word has to be free from myths.

      7 Many people today look for omens, cast spells, and consult spirit mediums. The spirits secretly invoked by such practices often harm innocent victims, including children. Since God is not evil, can scriptures having connections with such forms of demonism originate with him? All revelations of the true God will be free from demonism.

      8 We can also tell whether scripture is from God or from men by observing the fruits it produces in the lives of those who follow its teachings. Are they clean, honest, and hardworking, or are they deceitful, dishonest, and corrupt? Do they enjoy warm, loving family relationships, or do they accept the mistreatment of women and other people as normal? Are they people who know God personally, as a friend, or are they guided solely by religious leaders? A book of divine origin should provide solutions for our problems and have a good effect on our lives.

      9 These seven requirements, taken together, provide the standard by which to test all holy writings. When a book meets all of them, surely it comes from God!

      10 Let us now examine together different sacred writings and see how each measures up. Remember, we are interested in receiving divine guidance. Our Maker, like a caring father, also wants us to know his will so that we may love and worship him.

  • Sacred Writings of India
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 3

      Sacred Writings of India

      GURU NANAK AND THE GURU GRANTH SAHIB

      According to the Guru Granth Sahib, Guru Nanak, the founder of Sikhism, never fully acknowledged the authority of the Hindu scriptures because he objected to Vedic ceremonies, the caste system, and the worship of many gods. Tracing the source of Nanak’s beliefs, however, Sikh writer Khushwant Singh notes: “Even a casual reading of his hymns reveals the influence of the Rigveda, the Upanishads . . . , and the Bhagvad Gita.” So to understand the Guru Granth Sahib, we must examine the sources of its teachings—the Vedas, the Upanishads, and the Bhagavad Gita.—The Sikh Gurus and the Sikh Religion, Anil Chandra Banerjee, 1983, pages 133-4.

      BRAHMI—INDIA’S ROOT SCRIPT

      The scripts of Indian languages, such as Sanskrit, Hindi, Punjabi, Marathi, Malayalam, Tamil, and Bengali, have all “ultimately descended from Brahmi, the script used by the Emperor Ashoka in the 3rd century B.C. in the earliest surviving Indian inscriptions.”—Indian Manuscripts, The British Library, 1977, page 1.

      “Brāhmī, the traditional prototype of all Indo-Āryan scripts, may have been introduced in the eighth or seventh century B.C.”—A Dictionary of Hinduism, Margaret and James Stutley, 1977, page 267.

      THE VEDAS

      The earliest hymns of the four Vedas (Rig-Veda, Yajur-Veda, Sama-Veda, and Atharva-Veda) were composed nearly 3,000 years ago and were transmitted orally from teacher to pupil. “It was only in the fourteenth century A.D. that the Veda was written down.”—A History of India, P. K. Saratkumar, 1978, page 24.

      THE UPANISHADS

      Over a hundred treatises on Hindu philosophy and mysticism were composed about 2,500 years ago. “Though the earliest Upaniṣads were compiled by 500 B.C., they continued to be written even so late as the spread of Mahommedan influence in India.”—A History of Indian Philosophy, Surendranath Dasgupta, Indian edition 1975, Volume 1, page 39.

      THE PURANAS

      A class of Sanskrit writings of ancient tales and Hindu mythology. “None of the eighteen main Puranas are earlier than the Gupta Period (AD 320-480), although much of the legendary material is older.”—Hinduism, M. Stutley, 1985, page 37.

      MAHAVIRA AND THE AGAMAS

      The teachings embodied in the Jain scriptures, collectively called agamas, are attributed in part to Mahavira and his disciples. What was the source of their teaching?

      “The philosophy of Jainism draws its inspiration mainly from the atheistic Sankhya system,” notes Epics, Myths and Legends of India (P. Thomas, 1980, page 132). The Sankhya (also Samkhya) philosophy, in turn, is based on the Upanishads and teaches that liberation from suffering and rebirth is possible through right conduct and ascetic practices. So to understand Jain beliefs, we must consider their source—the Upanishads.

      THE GURU GRANTH SAHIB

      A collection of almost 6,000 hymns composed by various Sikh gurus as well as Hindu and Muslim mystics. “The Guru-Granth was compiled by the fifth Sikh Guru, Arjun, in 1604 A.D.”—Sri Guru Granth Sahib, translated by Dr. Gopal Singh, 1987, Volume 1, page XVIII.

      THE EPICS

      Ramayana relates the story of Rama, a prince who later ruled from the capital Ajodhya in northern India, and became deified as the seventh avatar of Vishnu.

      Mahabharata describes the conflict between two families for the rule of upper India nearly 3,000 years ago.

      “Both the Rāmāyaṇa of Vālmiki and the Mahābhārata of Vyāsa must have been completed between 500 B.C. and A.D. 200, the former in the first half of this period and the latter in the second half.”—Advanced History of India, K. A. Nilakanta Sastri and G. Srinivasachari, 1982, page 59.

      THE AGAMAS

      Jain scriptures compiled in Sanskrit and Prakrit on the life and teachings of Mahavira, who lived over 2,400 years ago. “The Śvetāmbara canon of scripture, which was not given definitive form until nearly A.D. 500, consists of approximately forty-five texts, in six groups.”—Abingdon Dictionary of Living Religions, edited by Keith Crim, 1981, page 371.

  • The Vedas—The Search for Truth
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 4

      The Vedas—The Search for Truth

      Of all the Hindu scriptures, the Vedas are the oldest and the most important. To this day, they are the main source of Hindu ceremonies performed at birth, marriage, and death. Their hymns reveal how worshipers seek God’s blessing and prosperity in everyday life.

      2 Orthodox Hindus believe the Vedas to be Sruti, revealed by God, and therefore free from error and imperfection. On the other hand, Buddha, revered by many as the ninth incarnation of Vishnu, rejected their authority, describing them as a ‘pathless jungle.’ Between these opposing views, there exist a variety of other beliefs.

      3 The rishis (seers) said that they composed the Vedic hymns with their own ‘ability and knowledge.’1 In a hymn to Agni, a rishi prays: “Inspired with poetry I have fashioned this hymn of praise for you . . . , as the skilled artist fashions a chariot.”2 Like poets and artists, rishis were moved from within themselves to compose over a thousand Vedic hymns. How important are these?

      Vedic Moral Code

      4 Guided by their consciences, the rishis point out the badness of immorality. They advise the gambler: “Play no longer with the dice, but till your field.”3 When troubled by a bad conscience, they pray: “If we humans have committed some offence against the race of gods, O Varuṇa, or through carelessness have violated your laws, do not injure us, O god, for that sin.”4

      5 Some of the rishis’ hymns draw upon our qualities of love and kindness. For example, family members are exhorted to be “attached to one another like the newly born calf to the cow. . . . Let the wife to the husband speak words full of honey, ever auspicious. Let not brother hate brother, nor sister sister.”5

      Rishis Search for Truth

      6 The Vedas reveal the rishis’ remarkable thirst for truth. They also reveal the limits of their understanding. To discover life’s meaning, they wonder about the origin of the universe: “What was the wood and what was the tree from which [the gods] carved the sky and the earth?” asks one rishi.6 Certain hymns indicate that matter existed before God, whereas others state that it was God who produced the matter that formed the universe.

      7 According to yet another hymn, the gods made the universe from the sacrifice of a cosmic man. “The moon was produced from his mind (manas), the sun (surya) from his eye, . . . from his head the sky, from his feet the earth.”7 From him also came the different castes and animals.

      8 Such explanations, however, did not fully satisfy those rishis who desired to know the truth. Therefore, as they conclude the Vedas, they still wonder: “Who knows the truth? Who can tell whence and how arose this universe? The [Vedic] gods are later than its beginning: who knows therefore whence comes this creation? Only that god who sees in highest heaven: he only knows whence came this universe, and whether it was made or uncreated. He only knows, or perhaps he knows not.”8

      9 The rishis addressed their hymns to such deified natural elements as the sun, sky, wind, and fire. But they did not view any one of these as the supreme deity. Consequently, in the last book of the Rig-Veda, they ask: “What God shall we adore with our oblation?”9 In other words, which of the 33 gods of the Vedas is the Creator whom we should worship in love and truth?

      10 At the completion of the Vedas, the rishis had not found the true God so as to worship him. They were still seeking him. The Vedas, therefore, are not a revelation of God’s truth but are a record of the rishis’ earnest search for it. The quest is now taken up in the Upanishads, the next great body of scriptures of India.

      [Box on page 10]

      The Vedas—Did You Know?

      “The Atharva Veda . . . was not originally recognised as having the canonical status of the other three Vedas. It grew up when the Adhvaryu priest began to cater to the masses and produce spells of magic and sorcery directed against diseases, enemies, demons.”—A New History of Sanskrit Literature, Krishna Chaitanya, 1962, page 33.

      [Box on page 11]

      How do the Vedas measure up to these criteria?

      They should:

      1. Magnify God and answer our questions about him

      2. Be free from myths

      3. Be free from demonism

      [Picture on page 10]

      Hindu rituals, such as those performed at birth, marriage, and death (see next page), are based on the Vedas

  • The Upanishads—The Love of Philosophy
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 5

      The Upanishads—The Love of Philosophy

      “All the philosophical systems and religions of India, heretical or orthodox, have sprung up from the Upanishads,” states the book The Vedic Age.1 It is in these compositions that the cycle of Karma and rebirth—the basic belief of Hindus, Jains, and Sikhs—is first taught. What else do they teach?

      Reflecting on Life’s Meaning

      2 The Upanishads continue the rishis’ search for truth that began in the Vedas. “The sages in the Upaniṣads had already started with the idea that there was a supreme controller or essence presiding over man and the universe,” notes Dr. S. Dasgupta. “But what was its nature? Could it be identified with any . . . new deity or was it no deity at all? The Upaniṣads present to us the history of this quest,” he adds.2

      3 In forest retreats, sages meditated on and debated such questions as: “What is the source of this universe? . . . From where do we come? By what power do we live? Where do we find rest [at death]? Who rules over our joys and sorrows?”3 Expecting to find answers through their own reason and experience, rather than by revelation from God, they said: “Tell us this, O you philosophers.”4

      The Fruits of Philosophy

      4 The sages attribute the creation of the world to Brahman, who, according to Isa Upanishad, is a being, separate from the universe. (Verse 1) The Mundaka Upanishad, on the other hand, regards Brahman as the universe itself. A third view, based on the Svetasvatara Upanishad, suggests that whereas Brahman is real, the universe is simply an illusion (maya).

      5 A creation account in the Chandogya Upanishad asserts that the world was born from a giant egg. On the origin of life, the Brihadarayanka Upanishad states that the Creator, feeling lonely and unhappy, “grew as large as a man and a woman entwined, and then divided himself in two, creating a husband and a wife. . . . In this way he created the male and female of all creatures—even down to the ants.”5

      6 What happens at death? According to Katha Upanishad, young Nachiketas approaches Yama, god of death, and asks: “When a man dies, this doubt arises: some say ‘he is’ and some say ‘he is not.’ Teach me the truth.” Yama answers: “Even the gods had this doubt in times of old; for mysterious is the law of life and death. Ask for another boon.”6 Nachiketas persists, however, and Yama eventually expounds the doctrine of rebirth.

      7 Describing this cycle of rebirth, the Chandogya Upanishad relates that at death a person’s soul goes to the moon, and it remains there until his “good works are consumed.”7 After that he falls as rain to the earth to be “born here as rice and barley, as herbs and trees.” He then must wait to enter a womb until “some one or other eats him as food and emits him as semen.”8 His caste, or life-form, is determined at his rebirth by his past Karma.

      The Search Continues

      8 Like the Vedas, “the Upanishads left some great issues unsettled,” notes the book India. “The individual Hindu is still free to decide whether he believes the one Supreme Reality is an impersonal . . . spirit . . . or a personal God. . . . Similarly the believer may decide that the world is one aspect of Brahman or Brahma, or that it is simply Its or His creation—or he may remain undecided.”9

      9 Although the teaching of Karma and rebirth is today viewed by devout Hindus as divinely revealed truth, in the book The Vedic Age we read that “the Upanishads do not contain ‘superhuman conceptions,’ but human, absolutely human attempts to come nearer to the truth.”10 Similarly, the book Advanced History of India notes: “The upanishads reveal the nature of guesses at Truth, from different standpoints; these guesses ultimately led to the evolution of [Indian] systems of philosophy.”11

      10 In order to know God’s truth, therefore, you need to continue your search beyond the Vedas and the Upanishads. By so doing, you will demonstrate that you truly love God and want to worship him in truth. So let us next examine the epics and the Bhagavad Gita, the foremost traditional Smriti scriptures. Can they help us in our search?

      [Box on page 13]

      The Upanishads—Did You Know?

      “Literally, [“Upanishad”] means sitting near devotedly, and so brings concretely to mind an earnest disciple learning from his guru, his spiritual master. It also means secret teaching—secret, no doubt, because a teaching vouchsafed only to those who are spiritually ready to receive it.”—The Spiritual Heritage of India, Swami Prabhavananda, 1980, page 39.

      [Box on page 13]

      How do the Upanishads measure up to these criteria?

      They should:

      1. Magnify God and answer our questions about him

      2. Be available to all

      3. Be easy to understand

      4. Teach true doctrines and morals

      5. Be free from myths

      [Picture on page 12, 13]

      The teaching of the cycle of Karma and rebirth originated with the Upanishads

  • The Epics—Truth and Fable
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 6

      The Epics—Truth and Fable

      “From the beginning the Rāmāyana and the Mahābhārata have exercised a profound influence upon India,” observes Swami Prabhavananda. Their legends “have supplied poets and dramatists, theologians and political thinkers, painters and sculptors, with their . . . never-failing inspiration.”1 Doubtless you are familiar with many of these legends. How do you view them?

      2 Today many Hindus look to the epics as a source of moral and spiritual guidance. Others consider them to have primarily historical rather than religious value. But do they contain truths about God and his worship?

      Elements of Truth

      3 “The great battle described in the Mahabharata may have a historical basis in the memory of a battle in north India in the tenth century BC,” suggests M. Stutley in Hinduism.2 Archaeologists have confirmed that some places this epic mentions did exist between 800 and 400 B.C.E. “The epic substance was enlarged and embellished” over the centuries, however, to include “a mass of legends, myths and fancies mixed up with morality, religion and philosophy,” notes the History of Philosophy Eastern and Western.3

      4 The Mahabharata’s story of Manu, who saved humanity from a global deluge, also contains some historical truth. The flood was “the most important landmark in the history of the ancient world, and common flood legends suggest that the same event has been described in Indian, Hebrew, and Babylonian accounts,” says The Vedic Age.4a

      5 That same book says that the story of Rama, when “divested of its miraculous, fabulous, incredible and mythological elements, clearly indicates that he [Rama] was a great king who spread Aryan ideas and institutions into regions far and wide.”5

      6 In addition to these historical features, the epics also contain moral and religious principles. For example, the Mahabharata encourages people to be hospitable, saying: “Even to foes who visit us as guests due hospitality should be displayed; the tree screens with its leaves, the man who fells it.”6 Elsewhere it says: “Heaven is not so pleased with costly gifts, offered in hope of future recompense, as with the merest trifle set apart from honest gains, and sanctified by faith.”7

      Imaginary Tales

      7 In contrast with these fine principles, however, the epics at times reflect the opinions of their compilers. In the Ramayana, for example, the earth is said to be supported by eight elephants who move when they are tired and thus cause earthquakes. The compilers were also unaware of the Himalayan source of the river Ganges. They thought it trickled from heaven.—Ramayana 1:40-44.

      8 Did you know that the writers of the Mahabharata adopted the prevailing view that women had been created only to corrupt chaste men to prevent them from gaining salvation? (Mahabharata 13:40) Even the Gita views women as of inferior birth and classes them with menial slaves. Do you believe this? Does it seem just and reasonable?—Bhagavad Gita 9:32.

      9 The absence of inspired Sruti led the epic writers to create fables in order to answer questions. In explaining death, for example, the Mahabharata states that at one time humans multiplied without dying and became so many that “there was no space to breathe.”8 Afraid that this would result in the ‘earth sinking into the waters,’ the Creator produced a goddess to bring death to humans either by diseases or by injury.—Mahabharata 12:248-250.

      10 According to Indian scholars, the compilers of the epics also created its legends. In the Gita, Krishna claims that he is God. Regarding this, Dr. S. Radhakrishnan states: “The poet Vyasa [who wrote it] vividly imagines how Krishna as an incarnate God would speak of himself.” Similarly, author M. Hariharan notes that “somebody else must have made Krishna God and made him perform the supernatural deeds.”9 In the Ramayana, Rama does not claim to be a god but merely a human suffering for his sins.—Ramayana 3:63, 64.

      Epics—The Choice

      11 The epic poems were originally sung at the courts of kings during great festivals held to proclaim the fame of the princes. Compilers later added religious fables.10 “The most brilliant of these additions,” notes D. D. Kosambi, “is the Bhagavad-Gītā, a discourse supposedly uttered by the god Krishna just before the fighting. The god himself was new; his supreme godhead would not be admitted for centuries afterwards.”11 In this way the epics came to include historical truths alongside religious fables.

      12 So as you continue your search for Sruti, a complete revelation of God’s truth, consider next the Puranas, upon which Hindu worship is based today.

      [Footnotes]

      a The Hebrew account, the oldest and most accurate, appears in Genesis 6-8, the Bible’s first book, chapters 6, 7, and 8.

      [Box on page 14]

      The Epics—Did You Know?

      “Embedded in one book of the great Indian epic the Mahābhārata occurs the Bhagavad-Gītā, or Song of God, the most popular work in all the religious literature of India. . . . Without fear of contradiction it may be said to be the Holy Bible of India, though, unlike the Upaniṣads, it is not regarded as Śruti, or revealed scripture, but only as Smṛti, or tradition elaborating the doctrines of the Upaniṣads.”—The Spiritual Heritage of India, Swami Prabhavananda, 1980, page 95.

      [Box on page 15]

      How do the epics measure up to these criteria?

      They should:

      1. Magnify God and answer our questions about him

      2. Teach true doctrines and morals

      3. Be free from myths

  • The Puranas and Hindu Worship Today
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 7

      The Puranas and Hindu Worship Today

      Present-day Hindu worship is based on the scriptures known as Puranas. Unlike the Vedas, they promote use of images, temple rituals, and pilgrimages to sacred places. Through such practices, worshipers seek God’s blessing in order to break free from the cycle of rebirth.

      2 “The Purāṇas have been called ‘the Veda of the common folk’, since they present much traditional and orthodox material through myth and legend, story and symbol,” notes Hindu World.1 Although the Puranas are not generally accepted by orthodox Brahmans and reformers, they are popular among ordinary Hindus. Can they help you to worship God in truth? Consider what they teach.

      Creation in the Puranas

      3 Influenced by Vedic ideas, the compilers of the Vishnu Purana believed that the universe consisted of seven upper stories, with the earth at the bottom, and seven lower stories, inhabited by a half-human, half-serpent race.

      4 In the Bhagavata Purana, the sun and moon are thought to revolve around the earth. The moon, because of a higher velocity, is said to overtake the sun during its orbit. The earth, resting on a cobra, is divided into continents that are separated by oceans of water, wine, and ghee.—Bhagavata Purana 5:16-22, 25.

      The Search for God

      5 The Puranas, like the Vedas and the Upanishads, continue the search for the true God. Although the sages adore many deities, they earnestly desire to know: “Which deity shall a devotee desiring liberation worship . . . ? Who is the god of gods?” What important questions these are!

      6 In reply the Brahma Purana notes that although Brahma, Vishnu, or Siva are worshiped, the true Creator is someone else.2 Confirming this point, Brahma states in the Bhagavata Purana that both he and Siva have yet to fathom the Creator’s nature.—Bhagavata Purana 2:6.

      7 Without a revelation from God, however, it was not possible for the sages to know God. As a result, some worshipers came to imagine him to be a human, an animal, or even half-human, half-beast. The Bhagavata Purana describes Vishnu as a fish “of golden colour, having a horn, and a body extending over ten million Yojanas.”3a The Vayu Purana portrays him as a dark-colored boar with a height of 4,000 miles [6,400 km].

      8 The compilers of Puranic legends also imagined that the gods had human weaknesses. The Brahmavai Purana states that the wise do not worship Brahma because he was cursed for having committed a gross wrong.4b Other Puranas describe Siva as “a bad provider [who] allowed his family to starve, while he himself indulged in opium and other drugs,” according to Hindu World.5

      9 Disturbed by reports of one deity’s relationships with local milkmaids, a king in the Bhagavata Purana asks: ‘How can the divine lord who was born to establish virtue and repress vice, practice its opposite, namely the corruption of other men’s wives?’7 To this the sage replies that if superior beings deviate from virtue, then it cannot be viewed as sin, just as blame cannot be attributed to fire if it consumes impure things.8

      Methods of Worship

      10 Puranic worship centers around carefully designed temples, or shrines. Their ground plans follow a mandala, which, according to Swami Harshananda, “is a geometric diagram with occult potentialities.”9 The temple’s most sacred object is the yantra, a gold plate with occult diagrams. In the past it was used by followers of Tantric sects who practiced the sexual rites depicted on the walls of great Hindu and Jain temples.

      11 Idols are bathed in water or milk by worshipers who hope to acquire wealth or good health. Then, according to the Brahmavai Purana, tilaks are applied to people’s foreheads to ensure the magical potency of rituals.10 Lamps are lit and flowers are offered to ward off evil spirits, as mantras are chanted in praise of deities or to seek their favor.

      12 The Skanda Purana traces the use of idols to a curse upon the gods by the goddess Parvati for their intrusion into her privacy. The Encyclopaedia of Puranic Beliefs and Practices states: “This seems to explain the [Hindu] practice of worshipping stone-blocks as gods, and also well carved out idols.”11

      What Will You Choose?

      13 The Puranas are classed as Smriti by Hindus because these writings are not divinely inspired but are of human origin. So if we earnestly desire God to accept our worship and bless us, we must continue our search for Sruti. What guidance can gurus give us?

      [Footnotes]

      a A yojana is an ancient measure of distance, varying from four to ten miles [6 to 16 km].

      b “In the whole of India, only one important temple—at Pushkar in Rajasthan—is dedicated to Brahma.”6—India, 1986, Time-Life Books, page 38.

      [Box on page 17]

      How do the Puranas measure up to these criteria?

      They should:

      1. Magnify God and answer our questions about him

      2. Teach true doctrines and morals

      3. Be free from myths

      4. Be free from demonism

      5. Provide solutions for our problems and have a good effect on our lives

      [Picture on page 16]

      Hindu temple worship and religious festivals are based on the Puranas

  • The Gurus—Their Role in Worship
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 8

      The Gurus—Their Role in Worship

      Swami Prabhavananda writes: “The direction of a competent teacher is essential if one is to attain to knowledge of God, for religion is a practical science to which neither books nor scriptures can be a complete guide.”1 For this reason many Hindus search for gurus who can help them work out a system of belief and worship.

      2 We certainly need guidance to understand spiritual truths. Since gurus are not dependent on scriptures, from what source are their teachings and miracles?

      The Origin of Guruism

      3 Guruism is first introduced in the Upanishads as a challenge to the authority of the Vedas. To replace costly Vedic rituals, the Upanishads promoted ‘secret knowledge’ as the means to salvation.2

      4 The rejection of the Vedas increased the importance of the gurus. Liberation, it was claimed, could be attained only after a person had been initiated by a guru and received a secret mantra or some other device. Says The World of Gurus: “Being indispensable, the guru also tended to become supreme, even above the scriptures. . . . His own authority, derived from his private mystical experience, was final.”3

      5 Having supplanted the scriptures, in effect, the gurus soon became identified with God. The guru is also God and it should not be debated, claims the Yogashikhopanishad.4 At his initiation, a guru is said to receive supernatural experiences from his deity while in a state of trance and is regarded thereafter as the embodiment of that deity. “The Guru is God Himself manifesting in a personal form to guide the aspirant,” explains Swami Sivananda.5

      6 Claiming equality with God, the gurus then add in the Upanishads: “One should worship with extreme devotion the guru who imparts divine wisdom, who is the spiritual guide, who is the Supreme Lord Himself.”6 Thus, notes Hindu World: “Lights are waved before him, incense burned in his presence, hymns are sung and prostrations made. . . . The guru’s feet are washed and the water in which this is done is passed around to his followers who drink it.”7

      Miracles—From What Source?

      7 Many people follow gurus because they are impressed by the gurus’ miracles, which the devotees attribute to God.a The Hindu scriptures, however, record that evil persons, such as Ravana, possessed similar supernatural powers. Is there, then, another source besides God for such powerful works?

      8 Gurus acquire their supernatural powers by practicing Yogic arts. But in the Yoga Sutra, Patanjali, the father of Yoga philosophy, attributes these powers to evil “celestial beings” whose chief aim is, according to Swami Vivekananda, “to tempt the Yogi” that he should not gain perfect freedom.8 The swami therefore “warned against striving for such sorcerous powers and stressed the need for totally avoiding them,” notes Tantrism.9

      Liberation—How Real?

      9 Ancient Hindus turned to Yoga to discover the ultimate truth that the Vedas failed to teach. The Katha Upanishad says that truth cannot be known through scriptures or by reason but by mystic experiences alone. (1:2:23) For this reason, the Hindu swami Sivananda states: “Intellect is a hindrance. That which separates you from God is mind.”10 So mystics practice Yogic meditation in order to dull the intellect and to experience trances or feelings of ecstasy. Those attaining such a state are said to have found truth and to have attained moksha.

      10 By emptying the mind and deadening the senses, a Yogi can see and hear strange things. “If, however, [Yogic] meditation has been combined, as it often is, with such other techniques as fasting, drug-taking, extreme isolation, and torturelike activities, the deprived [mental] state can be attended by bizarre hallucinations. It may also be attended by ‘mystical’ events of the kundalini type,” states Understanding Yoga.11b The Yogi is led to believe that these unusual experiences during his nonrational state are both real and good.

      11 Following this course, some Yogis claim to experience a oneness with the spirit world, which they say is God. In the book Mysticism Sacred and Profane, R. C. Zaehner warns: “This emptiness is dangerous for this is a ‘house swept and garnished,’ and though it is possible that God may enter in if the furniture is fair, it is equally likely that the proverbial seven devils will rush in if . . . there is no furniture at all.”12c For this reason gurus often warn new disciples that Yoga may expose them to demonic influence. Would such warnings be necessary if the true God were involved?

      12 Many gurus promote their personal beliefs, claiming that these are based on reliable scriptures. The Society for Krishna Consciousness, for example, asserts that its beliefs are founded on ‘the Vedic scriptures.’ On the other hand, The World of Gurus states: “No attempt is made to establish the authenticity of scriptures . . . If [the devotees] read the scriptures they would know that the stories of Krishna and Radha are not based on authoritative scriptures, much less on facts.”13

      13 Since gurus are guided by their personal experience and knowledge, where are you to look for God-revealed truth? Obviously, you need to consult scriptures that are truly inspired by God. Where can you find them?

      [Footnotes]

      a These include such things as clairvoyance, healing, levitation, and walking on fire.

      b Yogis describe kundalini as a mysterious energy that, like a coiled serpent, lies at the base of the spinal column. When it is aroused, either through physical or sexual exercises, the Yogi experiences strange sensations and visions, which he interprets to be a “liberation,” or the merging of his own self with God.

      c Zaehner is referring to the words of Jesus, recorded in the Bible book of Luke, chapter 11, verses 24-26.

      [Box on page 19]

      Yoga —Did You Know?

      “What might appear a superficial dabbling with pranayama [breathing exercises] and the asanas [Yogic postures], may turn out to be the first step along a path of occultism beset with potential hazards for the unsuspecting. The physical exercises of yoga are specifically designed to prepare the body for the psycho-spiritual changes that are to come. Down the ages yoga has been used first and foremost as a vestibule leading to the inner sanctuary of occult experience.”—Tantrism, Benjamin Walker, 1985, page 125.

  • Identifying God-Inspired Truth
    Why Should We Worship God in Love and Truth?
    • Chapter 9

      Identifying God-Inspired Truth

      Did you know that modern Hindu reformers such as Ramakrishna and Vivekenanda were influenced by the Bible? Mohandas Gandhi also maintained that its teachings can ‘solve the problems of the whole world.’ Both Hindus and Sikhs are indebted to it for their concept of bhakti, which, says Hindu World, resulted from “the impact of Christianity in the early centuries of the present era.”1 Thus, the Bible has earned the respect of great Indian thinkers.

      Scripture and Science

      2 Written nearly 3,500 years ago, the opening verse of the Bible described the origin of the universe, saying: “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.” (Genesis 1:1) In harmony with this statement, scientists now acknowledge that the universe did have a beginning, a genesis.2

      3 The source of matter in the universe, says the Bible, is “the abundance of [God’s] dynamic energy.” (Isaiah 40:26) Today, some 2,700 years after that was written, modern science has discovered that all matter is basically materialized energy.3

      4 At a time when men believed that the universe was made up of the few thousand stars they could see with unaided eyes, the Bible compared the number of stars to the grains of sand on the seashore. (Genesis 22:17) In the past this comparison was said to be greatly exaggerated, yet today the evidence shows that the number of stars is indeed incalculable.4 Similarly, far in advance of modern science, the Bible accurately described the earth as a “circle,” or globe, that is ‘hanging upon nothing.’—Isaiah 40:22; Job 26:7.

      5 The Bible states that Adam, the first man, was created “out of dust from the ground.” (Genesis 2:7) We now know that our human body is composed of a number of different chemical elements, all of which are found in the earth. Amazing insight is also evident in the Bible’s comment that ‘parts of a developing embryo are written down in a book.’ This was 3,000 years before modern science discovered the genetic code, which, like a book, contains all aspects of a growing human embryo.—Psalm 139:14-16.

      An Authentic Record

      6 Students of history are often amazed at the Bible’s accuracy. Says Indian scholar D. D. Kosambi: “The historical value of the Veda is rather small in comparison with that of the Old Testament of the Bible, which was always presented as history by people who retained contact with their particular land. The archaeology of Palestine . . . provides ample confirmation of many Biblical events.”5

      7 The Bible also records key events in world history and how these affected other nations, including India. Consider, for example, the Persian invasion of India in the fifth and sixth centuries B.C.E., in which Darius Hystaspis gained control of Sind and parts of Punjab, as they are now known. As noted in Advanced History of India, “this territory continued to form part of the Persian empire under Xerxes.”6 This historical fact was accurately recorded in the Bible at Esther 1:1 about the year 475 B.C.E.—one of the oldest known references to India.7

      A Clean Form of Worship

      8 The Bible tells us that there is one true God. Only in the Bible has he revealed to us his name, JEHOVAH. There he states: “Before me there was no God formed, and after me there continued to be none.” Jehovah, therefore, does not have avatars, nor does he exist in different aspects. All the qualities and forces needed to sustain creation exist in him alone. “To whom can you people liken God, and what likeness can you put alongside him?” the prophet asks.—Isaiah 40:18; 43:10.

      9 In Jehovah’s worship, it is clean conduct, not ritual, that is required for his blessing. God says: “Of what benefit to me is the multitude of your sacrifices? . . . Incense—it is something detestable to me. New moon and sabbath, the calling of a convention—I cannot put up with the use of uncanny power along with the solemn assembly. . . . Even though you make many prayers, I am not listening; . . . cease to do bad. Learn to do good.”—Isaiah 1:11-17.

      10 Those who live by the Bible are well protected from the dangers of spiritism. It counsels: “There should not be found in you anyone who makes his son or his daughter pass through the fire, . . . anyone who looks for omens or a sorcerer, or one who binds others with a spell or anyone who consults a spirit medium or a professional foreteller of events or anyone who inquires of the dead. For everybody doing these things is something detestable to Jehovah.”—Deuteronomy 18:10-12.

      A Superior Moral Code

      11 Another important difference between the Bible and other holy books is its power to help us lead better lives. For example, it states: “Let the stealer steal no more, but rather let him do hard work, doing with his hands what is good work, that he may have something to distribute to someone in need. Let a rotten saying not proceed out of your mouth, but whatever saying is good for building up as the need may be . . . Let all malicious bitterness and anger . . . be taken away from you along with all badness. But become kind to one another.” (Ephesians 4:28-32) What fine counsel!

      12 The superiority of the Bible’s moral code is also evident in its appeal to a person’s love for God. For instance, it exhorts women: “Do not let your adornment be that of the external braiding of the hair and of the putting on of gold ornaments or the wearing of outer garments, but let it be the secret person of the heart in the incorruptible apparel of the quiet and mild spirit, which is of great value in the eyes of God.” Husbands are similarly counseled to ‘assign honor’ to their wives “in order for [their] prayers not to be hindered.”—1 Peter 3:3, 4, 7.

      The Greatest Evidence of All

      13 Is the God of the Bible the true and living God? In order to prove his Godship, Jehovah invites the gods of other religions to a test. “Summon the nations to come to the trial,” he says. “Which of their gods can predict the future? Which of them foretold what is happening now? Let these gods bring in their witnesses to prove that they are right.”—Isaiah 43:9, Today’s English Version.

      14 Who has been able to explain the significant events of today’s world? Nearly 2,000 years ago, the Bible accurately foretold the turmoil that the world has witnessed since the year 1914. It said: “Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom; and there will be great earthquakes, and in one place after another pestilences and food shortages.” (Luke 21:10, 11) In contrast with Hindu teachings, the Bible, now translated in whole or in part into some 2,000 languages and dialects, contains true prophecy, which we are seeing fulfilled in our day.

      15 Decades before World War I began in 1914, Jehovah’s worshipers were making known the significance of that year. The New York World of August 30, 1914, explains: “The terrific war outbreak in Europe has fulfilled an extraordinary prophecy. For a quarter of a century past, through preachers and through press, the ‘International Bible Students’ [as Jehovah’s Witnesses were then known] . . . have been proclaiming to the world that the Day of Wrath prophesied in the Bible would dawn in 1914.”8 Ever since the momentous events of that year, so accurately foretold in the Bible alone, the whole world system of things has been in its “last days.”—2 Timothy 3:1-5.

      16 The fulfillment of many other Bible prophecies establishes it as “inspired of God.”a (2 Timothy 3:16) Therefore, you can have complete confidence in the things it teaches and foretells. This includes God’s purpose soon to rid the earth of all religion that dishonors God (as bloodguilty Christendom has done) and to establish peace and harmony between all races of mankind forever. (Revelation 18:4, 5) It is urgent that you heed the exhortation: “Fear God and give him glory, because the hour of the judgment by him has arrived, and so worship the One who made the heaven and the earth.” (Revelation 14:7) What does this require?

English Publications (1950-2026)
Log Out
Log In
  • English
  • Share
  • Preferences
  • Copyright © 2025 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Privacy Settings
  • JW.ORG
  • Log In
Share